Therefore the comparison between the two should not be about war, but about inhuman conditions and about betrayal – Jews in “Refugee Blues” and soldiers in “Disabled”. Nevertheless, it shouldn’t be assumed that Auden wasn’t exposed to war – he was a civilian asset for the Republic during the Spanish Civil War as well as. Refugee Blues and Disabled Comparison (Almost Finished) Words | 10 Pages "Disabled" / "Refugee Blues": A Poem Comparison Essay The subject of war and the loss of human life has had a deep influence on poetry of the first half of the 20th century.
Sorry, but copying text is forbidden on this website! The subject of war and the loss of human life has had a deep influence on poetry of the first half of the 20th century. Many poets from around the world had felt the direct impact of earth-shattering wars and went ddisabled to express their opinions through their works. Auden respectively. The title gives a glimpse comparison refugee blues disabled dating what the poem is about — a lonely soldier forced to be bluea.
The title gives a glimpse of what the poem is about — a lonely soldier forced to be amputated. The context of the poem takes place in Britain during its involvement in the Great War and tells a story of a disabled hence the title soldier who resides in a hospital.
To shock the readers, Owen reveals that the soldier is actually a young adolescent, aged , who returning from the Western Front, was forced to have his limbs amputated. Auden in — the year World War Two broke out. The name of the title is a reference to an old musical genre — blues.
They were originally sang by early African slaves on American soil. The songs of the particular genre were mostly about sadness and depression.
The story within tells about a German Jew and his wife, both taking numerous attempts to escape their homeland in hopes for salvation as their life becomes that of downward spiral following the rise of the fascist regime.
Although the poets Wilfred Owen and W. Auden express their attitudes differently, it can be considered that both voice their opinion on the same side of the arguement.
This is most probably because, the two poems were written during different political eras, the Great War and the Second World War.
A widely-considered opinion that soldiers are state-sponsored killers is being turned down by the poet to show how these young, inexperienced and unwilling men are being put in position that is a matter of life and death, from which, most who manage to return are either scarred mentally or broken physically. Whereas W.
There is only one occasion in the entire poem where the soldiers who serve the regime appear — at the very end. Their primary purpose there was to destroy any sense of optimism left in the poem. The quote to represent that is: However, this deteriorates by the end of the poem which concludes with feelings of hopelessness just like in Disabled.
In both poems this hopelessness is signified by the central character giving up hope and accepting defeat. These feelings continue throughout the poem, eventually amalgamating and becoming too much for the veteran who gets angry shown by the exclamation point and eventually begs for death.
Refugee Blues has a similar start with feelings of despair and hopelessness simply created by caesura and language. However, this hope is short-lived and by the end of the poem gradually deteriorates into the refugee giving up. Owen and Auden use the perspective and form in their poems in order to subtly criticise society and the way that it puts people into exile and how it treats the disabled.
During Disabled the viewpoint changes as the tense changes. This is contrasted by the subjective view that is taken when describing the past. This change in viewpoint is representative, and critical, of the way that society views disabled people and more generally those in isolation.
Auden also subtly criticises society, however, he does so by using the form of the poem. Auden uses the blues form to present exile because it originated from black African slaves in America. The form of the poem demonstrates how discrimination, and therefore isolation and exile, are engrained in society because of the ironic use of a form which originated from black slaves in a poem which is supposed to give a voice to those in isolation and exile.
Auden also uses the form of Refugee Blues in order to expose the lack of voice for those seeking refuge. The whole poem is written as if it is a conversation or a description to a loved one. This not only emphasises the entrapment through the same technique as Owen employs in Disabled inability to communicate with society shows that the refugee is trapped by exile but also seems to be like a Ghazal.
Traditionally, a Ghazal is written in order to express love which is usually unrequited or impossible. An honest journalist will find a real person. A dishonest journalist or a poet can invent a character. Step 2: Compare the past and the present. But what makes a good character? Over two thousand years ago the philosopher Aristotle wrote about Greek Tragedy. He thought tragedy inspires pity and fear.
He thought that we pity a character who does not deserve his bad luck. He thought we feel fear if we ourselves are similar to the character. Therefore a good character is somebody like us who suffers undeservedly. In both poems the characters have bad luck and the poets clearly do not think that they deserved it. In both poems the characters seem ordinary. The soldier is a typical volunteer. Auden tells us nothing about the Jew himself but this allows us to imagine he is like us.